Top True Crime Podcasts to Follow
- Mark H Roe
- Dec 8, 2025
- 5 min read
There’s something about the quiet crackle of a podcast playing in the background that pulls me in. It’s like stepping into a shadowy room filled with whispered secrets and untold stories. True crime podcasts have a way of weaving history, mystery, and human nature into a tapestry that’s both chilling and captivating. Over the years, I’ve found myself drawn to these narratives, not just for the thrill, but for the way they preserve stories that might otherwise fade away. If you share this fascination, you’re in for a treat. Let’s explore some of the top popular true crime podcasts that deserve a spot on your playlist.
Why Popular True Crime Podcasts Captivate Us
True crime stories tap into something primal. They remind us of the fragility of life and the complexity of human behavior. But beyond the shock and suspense, these podcasts often serve as a form of storytelling that preserves local histories and forgotten tales. They bring to light the voices of victims, the intricacies of investigations, and sometimes, the eerie paranormal whispers that linger in the background.
What makes popular true crime podcasts stand out is their ability to blend meticulous research with compelling narration. They don’t just recount facts; they invite us to walk alongside the storytellers, piecing together clues and reflecting on the broader implications. For those who love local history and paranormal lore, these podcasts offer a unique window into the past, often revealing stories that have been buried by time.
Top Popular True Crime Podcasts You Shouldn’t Miss
Here’s a curated list of some of the most engaging and well-crafted true crime podcasts that have captured the attention of listeners worldwide. Each one offers a different flavor of storytelling, from deep dives into cold cases to explorations of paranormal mysteries intertwined with crime.
1. Serial
No list of true crime podcasts is complete without mentioning Serial. This groundbreaking series set the standard for investigative storytelling in podcast form. Season one, which revisits the 1999 murder of Hae Min Lee, is a masterclass in narrative pacing and journalistic integrity. It’s a perfect example of how a podcast can bring new life to a cold case, encouraging listeners to question and reflect.
2. Criminal
Criminal takes a broader approach, telling stories about people who’ve done wrong, been wronged, or gotten caught somewhere in the middle. The episodes are short but packed with rich detail and thoughtful commentary. It’s a podcast that respects the complexity of crime and the human stories behind it.
3. My Favorite Murder
If you prefer a conversational style with a touch of humor, My Favorite Murder might be your go-to. Hosts Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark blend true crime with personal anecdotes, creating a community of listeners who share a fascination with the macabre. It’s a reminder that even the darkest stories can be approached with empathy and a bit of lightness.
4. Casefile
For those who appreciate a straightforward, no-nonsense approach, Casefile delivers. The anonymous host narrates cases with a calm, measured tone that lets the facts speak for themselves. The podcast covers a wide range of cases, from well-known crimes to obscure mysteries, often with a focus on local histories and lesser-known details.
5. Lore
While not strictly a true crime podcast, Lore explores the darker side of history and folklore, often touching on paranormal elements. Aaron Mahnke’s storytelling style is immersive and reflective, perfect for those who enjoy the intersection of crime, history, and the supernatural.
What is the number one true crime podcast?
Determining the number one true crime podcast can be subjective, depending on what you value most—storytelling style, depth of research, or entertainment value. However, Serial often holds the crown due to its pioneering role and widespread acclaim. It not only sparked a true crime podcast boom but also demonstrated the power of audio storytelling to influence public opinion and even legal outcomes.
That said, the best podcast for you might be different. Some prefer the intimate, conversational tone of My Favorite Murder, while others gravitate toward the investigative rigor of Casefile. The beauty of the genre is its diversity, offering something for every listener’s taste.
How to Choose the Right True Crime Podcast for You
With so many options available, picking the right podcast can feel overwhelming. Here are some tips to help you find the perfect match:
Consider your mood: Do you want a deep dive into a single case or a variety of shorter stories?
Think about tone: Some podcasts are serious and somber, others are lighthearted or even humorous.
Look for local flavor: If you’re interested in local history, seek out podcasts that focus on your region or similar communities.
Check episode length: Some podcasts offer bite-sized episodes, while others are more like audio documentaries.
Read reviews: Listener feedback can give you a sense of the podcast’s style and quality.
By reflecting on these factors, you can curate a listening experience that feels both engaging and meaningful.
Why I Keep Coming Back to True Crime Podcasts
For me, these podcasts are more than just entertainment. They are a way to connect with stories that might otherwise be lost to time. Each episode is like opening a dusty book in a forgotten library, revealing tales of human triumph, tragedy, and mystery. They remind me that history is alive, breathing through the voices of those who tell it.
Listening to a true crime podcast is like sitting by a campfire, sharing stories that have been passed down through generations. It’s a ritual that honors the past and keeps these narratives alive. And in a world that moves so fast, there’s comfort in slowing down to listen, reflect, and remember.
If you’re ready to dive into this world, I hope this list helps you find your next favorite podcast. Each one offers a unique journey into the shadows, where history, crime, and sometimes the paranormal, intertwine.
Happy listening, and may these stories inspire you to explore the hidden corners of our shared past.
If you love the way true crime podcasts unravel mysteries and bring hidden stories to light, you’ll find the same atmosphere in my books. I explore haunted Ohio folklore, unsolved mysteries, and chilling true crime tales with a storyteller’s eye for detail and suspense.
You can discover more of my work — from paranormal history to folklore‑rich mysteries — on my website at http://www.markhroe.com and on my Amazon Author Page: https://www.amazon.com/author/markhroe
Step into the shadows, follow the whispers, and see where the stories lead.
Comments